The Failed Bitcoin Experiment You’ve Never Heard Of…
0 up · 0 down · 0 ratings
Description
Because back in 2021, El Salvador became the first country in the world to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender. The government launched a national wallet called Chivo. They required businesses to accept it as a payment, and even gave every citizen $30 worth of free Bitcoin as an incentive for people to try it. It was finally time. This was Bitcoin's magnum opus moment. The moment where Bitcoin finally showed the world it could function as a real monetary system. And the results? Well, it was a huge failure. because according to IMF data, Bitcoin accounted for less than 2% of El Salvador's remittances, which is a huge deal because remittances were supposed to be Bitcoin's magical use case that it would allow people to send money across borders without banks, fees, and without friction. And when people actually had the option to use Bitcoin to do so, nobody did it.
In 2021, El Salvador became the first country to adopt Bitcoin as legal tender, with the government rolling out a national wallet called Chivo. The policy required businesses to accept Bitcoin payments and offered citizens $30 worth of free Bitcoin to encourage adoption. The video frames this as Bitcoin’s major “monetary system” test, positioning remittances as the key use case that would let people send money across borders without banks, fees, or friction. However, it reports a sharp gap between the goal and the outcome. Using IMF data, it says Bitcoin accounted for less than 2% of El Salvador’s remittances, and therefore the “magical” borderless payments narrative did not materialize. The segment closes on the conclusion that once people had the option, nobody used Bitcoin for that purpose.
Viewers strongly debate whether Bitcoin can function as money. Several commenters argue Bitcoin will never be a viable currency, citing volatility, speculative behavior, high transaction costs, and the lack of real-world enforcement or everyday usability. Others push back, saying Bitcoin can be useful for remittances or specific use cases, framing it as a tool or pipeline rather than a replacement for currency, and comparing it to experiences in other countries. There is also humor and incredulity in questions like “Name one country,” and calls for an “apology video” if Bitcoin hits new highs. Confusion and practical concerns come up repeatedly, including barriers to exchanging Bitcoin for cash and whether people can actually spend it where they live.
Topics · business · finance · economics · markets
Questions answered
- What did El Salvador launch when it adopted Bitcoin as legal tender in 2021?
- El Salvador launched a national wallet called Chivo.
- How did the El Salvador Bitcoin rollout incentivize citizens to try it?
- The government gave every citizen $30 worth of free Bitcoin as an incentive.
- What does the video claim about Bitcoin’s share of El Salvador remittances based on IMF data?
- It says Bitcoin accounted for less than 2% of El Salvador’s remittances.
- What was Bitcoin supposed to solve for cross-border remittances in the video’s framing?
- It was presented as enabling people to send money across borders without banks, fees, and without friction.