Apple iMac 2019 vs Tricked-Out Macbook Pro
0 up · 0 down · 0 ratings
Promos
Monitor and manage your PC in real-time with Pulseway! Create your free account today at lmg.gg Use code LINUS and get 25% off GlassWire at lmg.gg Our iMac review was pretty positive, but we got to thinking: If we’re going to want external graphics anyway, does a Macbook just make more sense? Buy a Radeon VII: On Amazon: geni.us On Newegg: lmg.gg Buy a Razer Core: On Amazon: geni.us On Newegg: lmg.gg Buy a MacBook Pro: On Amazon: geni.us From Apple: lmg.gg Buy a 2019 iMac: From Apple: lmg.gg Discuss on the forum: linustechtips.com Our Affiliates, Referral Programs, and Sponsors: linustechtips.com Get Private Internet Access today at geni.us Displate metal posters: lmg.gg Linus Tech Tips merchandise at lttstore.com Linus Tech Tips posters at crowdmade.com Our Test Benches on Amazon: amazon.com Our production gear: geni.us Twitter - twitter.com Facebook - @LinusTech Instagram - @linustech Twitch - twitch.tv Intro Screen Music Credit: Title: Laszlo - Supernova Video Link: youtube.com iTunes Download Link: itunes.apple.com Artist Link: soundcloud.com Outro Screen Music Credit: Approaching Nirvana - Sugar High youtube.com
The video sets up a head-to-head analysis between a 2019 iMac and a fully upgraded MacBook Pro, with the central question of whether a desktop or a premium laptop better serves graphics professionals. The hosts acknowledge that both machines share a similar upgrade path through Thunderbolt 3, which reframes the comparison beyond traditional desktop versus laptop distinctions. They outline three initial premises: both devices target professionals like graphic designers, both configurations use a discrete AMD GPU, and both suffer thermal constraints that affect peak performance. A baseline Cinebench run establishes CPU performance, highlighting that the MacBook Pro gains more from its cores while the iMac may hold an edge due to its multi-core capacity and thermal management. The discussion then shifts to real-world workloads such as disk speed, rendering, and video editing, with tests in Blackmagic Disk Speed, LuxMark, and Adobe Premiere/Final Cut to gauge how each system handles multi-threaded tasks, real-time previews, and export times. The hosts observe that the iMac can outperform the MacBook Pro in certain scenarios, particularly when the external GPU upgrade is in play, but the MacBook Pro remains highly competitive, especially when mobility and upgradability are factored in. They conclude that a well-equipped MacBook Pro with an external GPU can close the gap with the iMac, while noting the iMac’s superior sustained performance in some tasks and its stationary, non-portable nature. The video ends with practical buying guidance, acknowledging the trade-offs between portability, power, display size, and total cost, and recommending an external GPU approach for those who still need laptop versatility. Throughout, the hosts emphasize that the choice depends on whether portability or raw desktop power better matches the user’s workflow, and they caution against beta OS versions for professional use while offering testing data to support their conclusion. The sponsor segment is integrated mid-video, followed by a recap that subscriptions, merch, and the forum are available for viewers who want to engage further.
Topics · technology · hardware · computers · product-review · graphics · testing · consumer-electronics
Questions answered
- Which setup provides better sustained performance for graphic workloads, the iMac with Radeon 7 or the MacBook Pro with external GPU?
- Based on the benchmarks in the video, the iMac often shows stronger sustained performance, especially when configured with an external GPU, but a well-equipped MacBook Pro can approach or match that performance for many tasks depending on workload and cooling.
- Is upgrading the MacBook Pro with an external GPU a more cost-effective path than buying a more powerful iMac?
- The video suggests that an external GPU route for the MacBook Pro can be a cost-efficient way to close the gap with a desktop, particularly if mobility is required and you already own a laptop, though total costs vary with GPU availability and enclosure prices.