Entry № 041-15 / V-200 · 0:00 synced

Why Your Economists Suck

Garys Economics@garyseconomics169.6K viewsJun 11, 202325:37
Source
YT
Views
169.6K
Subscribers
1.6M
Critic
?
Audience
?

0 up · 0 down · 0 ratings

Channels and socials

"Academia are trying to write fancy papers, Media are trying to present professional looking content but none of them really care about being right. In the central bank they they are slightly more tied to reality but as you can see the central bank has done a phenomenally poor job of managing inflation in the last few years and they've done a phenomenally poor job of managing the economy in the last 20 years, you know & does anybody get fired? does anybody get fined?" UNDERSTAND, SHARE & PUSH BACK WEBSITE - garyseconomics.org TWITTER - twitter.com FACEBOOK - @garyseconomics INSTAGRAM - @garyseconomics TIKTOK - @garyseconomics YOUTUBE - youtube.com PATREON - patreon.com DISCORD - discord.gg SUBSCRIBE, SHARE & START A CONVERSATION Performed by Gary Stevenson @garyseconomics Produced by Simran Mohan @mohanmedia TIMESTAMPS 00:00 - They're Don't Care! (Highlight) 00:22 - It affects YOU 01:07 - Universities 03:50 - Graduating 06:48 - 2 Worlds 08:42 - Traders 11:08 - Academia 14:27 - The Media 17:00 - The Government 18:45 - The Solution 22:39 - Conclusion

Start
AI OverviewDefault language

Gary Stevenson, in this provocative examination of the economics profession, argues that the field is structurally arranged to reward the wrong incentives. He starts by mapping the pipeline from elite universities to two separate career tracks: public facing economists who engage with media, policy, and think tanks, and the highly paid traders who operate largely out of sight in finance. He asserts that the latter group earns enormous salaries and wields real influence, but their work is rarely in the public eye, while the former group is visible but often poorly rewarded for accuracy. The central claim is that the public-facing economics ecosystem,academia, media, and government,tends to prioritize appearance and mathematical elegance over practical truth. This misalignment, he suggests, helps explain persistent mispredictions and policy missteps across inflation, housing, and inequality. The video sets up a framework for understanding how incentives shape who gets heard, who gets funded, and who gets celebrated or fired when predictions miss the mark.

Topics · economy · education · media · government · inequality · finance

Questions answered

Waarom gaat Gary volgens hem de public facing economie zo slecht betaalde en minder verantwoordelijke positie beschrijven als waar model en realiteit botsen?
Hij stelt dat de publieke economen worden gemotiveerd door minder winstgevendheid en minder prikkels om accurate voorspellingen te doen, terwijl de economische elite in finance hoge salarissen krijgt en weinig verantwoording hoeft af te leggen voor verkeerde voorspellingen.
Welke oplossingen noemt Gary om de economische besluitvorming te verbeteren?
Hij pleit voor meer transparantie en verantwoording in publieke economie, duidelijke voorspellingen en evaluatie van wie het goed raadt, en het versterken van de positie van bekwame, publiek werkende economen boven de publieke elite.