AI the Product vs AI the Feature
0 up · 0 down · 0 ratings
Promos
The new Siri vs the RabbitR1 and Humane pin Rabbit R1: youtu.be Humane AI pin: youtu.be MKBHD Merch: shop.mkbhd.com Tech I'm using right now: amazon.com Intro Track: Logic logic.lnk.to Playlist of MKBHD Intro music: goo.gl ~ twitter.com @MKBHD @MKBHD
The video explores a provocative question that has become central to consumer technology: is artificial intelligence best understood as a feature or as a standalone product? The host anchors this in a comparison betweenAI as a product like the Humane AI Pin or the Rabbit R1 and AI as a feature that gets embedded into existing platforms, such as Apple’s OS updates announced at WWDC. He uses the Clubhouse rise and fall as a historical lens: a simple live audio idea that flourished briefly, then was absorbed into larger apps as a feature, leading to its decline as an independent product. The discussion then shifts to Apple’s strategy, which blends on device model training with new semantic capabilities in Siri and native writing tools, image generation, and emoji creation as integrated features rather than separate products. The central question becomes whether AI will follow the path of standalone products that dominate the market, or become a ubiquitous feature that enhances many platforms, potentially outlasting dedicated devices. The host notes the high barrier to entry for new players, since major models are now being built and licensed by large incumbents like Apple, Google, and Microsoft, making it difficult for smaller companies to compete. He closes by inviting audience input on whether AI will ultimately be a product, a feature, or both, and suggests that the trend points toward AI becoming a widely adopted feature across devices and apps. The overall takeaway is that the long-term trajectory favors integration and ubiquity of AI features rather than standalone AI products, though the final outcome remains unsettled and context dependent.
Topics · technology · ai · consumer-tech · product-management
Questions answered
- What is the core distinction made between AI as a product and AI as a feature?
- AI as a product is a standalone offering that users interact with directly, while AI as a feature is embedded into existing products and services to enhance their capabilities.
- Why does the host think AI will likely become a feature rather than a standalone product?
- Because major platforms are integrating AI capabilities across OSes and apps, creating broad reach and utility that outlasts single hardware devices, and because successful standalone products in AI have historically struggled to sustain themselves against platform-level integration.
- What historical example is used to illustrate the feature versus product dynamic?
- Clubhouse is used as a case where a standalone product rose quickly but mostly disappeared when its concept was absorbed as a feature by larger apps with built in audiences.
- Which companies are highlighted as having a strong on-device AI strategy?
- Apple is highlighted for building its own models and offering AI features across iOS, with a focus on on-device processing and integrated ChatGPT-like capabilities.